Hipper-than-thou pastor

So, if you know me personally, or if you even read this blog very regularly, you know that I have somewhat of a love-hate relationship with Rob Bell.

And right off the bat, let me tell you that I hate that, because self-righteous ‘christians’ who think it’s their goal in life to tear down everything their brothers build in the name of ‘constructive criticism’ drive me insane.

And to be totally honest, I’m somewhat of a hypocrite when it comes to this matter…

About a year ago, I read “Velvit Elvis”, and I like it so much that I read it again and then bought the audio from iTunes so I could make Stephanie listen to it :0)

(I wrote this about a year ago when I was thinking through the book)

The whole concept of interpreting what Jesus said through the grid of first century Judaism was amazing to me. And Rob really shed some light on some passages of scripture that never quite made sense.

I started listening to the Mars Hill Bible Church podcast. And for my birthday, I asked for the book ‘Sex God’, which I got and eagerly read…

This whole time, I had some questions I was holding out to find the answers to. But I felt like the good outweighed the bad, and I really wanted to give the guy the benefit of the doubt.

Then came the ‘Convergent’ conference at Southeastern seminary, and Mark Driscoll used his teaching time to speak about the ‘Emerging Church’, which I found really interesting. He singled out Rob along with a couple other teachers as ‘dangerous’. His explanation on why was fair and it caught my attention: It seems like the dude NEVER actually teaches the Gospel. And I got to thinking about it. And I started listening to Rob’s podcasts more carefully. And it’s my conclusion that after listening to a year’s worth of sermons, I still haven’t heard him teach about the cross one time! I have never been to Grand Rapids, and I don’t know what kind of systems/groups/processes they have in place there. But based solely on the Sunday morning teaching, it seems like you could have gone to Mars Hill Bible church for a whole year, been involved, paid attention, and never heard the Gospel articulated… (and I fully aknowledge that I’m really not qualified to make that assessment based on some podcasts…)


So, having said all that, there’s an article in Time magazine this week titled “The Hipper-Than-Thou Pastor”.

Some quotes from the article:

Polling by the evangelically oriented Barna research group shows that at least half of regular churchgoers ages 16 to 29 think their church is too judgmental, too political and too negative about homosexuality…

“He could be one of the most important 21st century Christian leaders,” says Bible professor and evangelical blogger Ben Witherington…

His stagecraft is legendary. To illustrate a passage from Leviticus on sacrifice, Bell brought on a live goat, which he released–underlining Jesus’ role as the last and greatest sin offering–intoning, “The goat has left the building.”

Hmmm… that last quote seems to come from a sermon that I missed…

Justin Taylor pointed to this story a couple days ago, and as of this morning, there are 44 comments, but the conversation there is awkward, because it seems like a couple of self-righteous religious people must be poised at their computers, waiting to explain to every Bell supported why they’re wrong….

The truth is, folks, that 11,000 people come to hear Rob preach every week. And even though I have my questions, I think I would much rather be a part of the community he’s helping to build that 99% of the churches within 30 miles of my house…

So what do we do with all this?



5 Responses

  1. This post caught my attention because a friend of mine just posted on this a couple of days ago, with the exact same title, and the exact same picture…funny how people think alike (I’m not implying you copied, I just think it’s funny). He offers a slightly different perspective. If you’re interested, click here to view his post.

  2. Hey Laura,

    Thanks for the comment!

    Yeah, I know this is kind of ‘old news’ in the blogosphere where the lifespan of a topic is like 12 hours…

    But this particular ‘discussion’ really matters to me, so I’ll be sure to check out that post you recommended.

    And just ’cause you mentioned it: The title and the picture both come from the article itself, which is probably why it looks familiar :0)

  3. if we continue to lose church members and (more importantly) Christians to Rob Bell’s slick gospel-less presentations (including words like repentance, sin, atonement…), we will lose the gospel itself in that generation of uber-cool black rimmed glasses.

    i’m scared of rob bell, for the sake of the church leadership of 2020 AD. time will tell, i guess…

  4. Yeah, I really feel ya brother…

    Based on his books alone, I would say that he toes the line without crossing it, but some of the Nooma stuff seems more like self help ideology.

    And I can even deal with that, but the fact that he had Doug Paggit in his pulpit really disturbs me.

    This is a guy who says that a muslim and a christian have the same eternity. And in a recent podcast interview, he bashes John Piper, basically saying that his (Doug’s) mission in life is to free the world from such religious, masochistic teachers….

    But there’s some good to take away from what these guys are doing…

    They’re creative.

    I listened to a Bell ‘sermon’/speech about having faith like a child, and he spread out these huge coloring books all around the stage, and called up all the children in the room to color while he taught.
    He paused periodically to ask the children questions and to comment on their art…

    And without even being there to watch, i was affected just by listening…

    For the sake of church leadership in 2020, we need to chew up the meat and spit out the bones…

  5. […] listen to lots of sermons/talks by guys like John Piper, Francis Chan, Louie Giglio, Mark Driscoll, Rob Bell (yes, I think it’s good to listen to people you don’t necessarily agree with), Any […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: